Soulmate or Strollmate?

2007 May 30
by commonplacer

In this season of love, a colleague threw out a question in the staffroom: “do you believe in soulmates?” A lively discussion followed with several of the younger staff stating that everyone had many soulmates, some of the older ones stating “NO” emphatically and others debating what the definition of a soulmate was. I was silent, silently thinking about this thing called love.

There’s a line in Irish singer, Ronan Keating’s love song When You Say Nothing At All that says, “all day long, I hear people talking out loud” which sums up what’s happening around me in the very young place I work at. It seems like everyone’s either in love or fresh out of love, ready for the next “soulmate”.

This is a topic which has perpetually confused me. Perhaps the confusion began in grade 3 when I dreaded going out to recess because there was a Gary waiting almost every day to chase me around the school yard, swinging his backpack (don’t know why he always had that thing at recess), wanting to play kissing tag. I was more befuddled in grade 8 when the teacher left our classroom “party” and it promptly turned into a “prom” and the local female bully forced me with clenched fists to dance with her best friend, a slight timid boy who had a crush on me. That was the one and last time I ever danced with a boy.

Of course I was brought up in a very sanitized way when it came to matters having to do with boys. In the beginnings of high school, such things were not discussed at home. There was childhood and play-with-everyone (we were never strictly told don’t play with the boys – in fact, my sister and I frequently had my brothers and their friends change their clubhouse signs willingly from boys only to boys only + h and s and, we had the most awesome time climbing trees with the best of them) and then…there was supposed to be adulthood and marriage.

The in-between was the tricky part my parents never imagined navigating. So in grade 10, when my mom sent my sister to throw the garbage down the chute and she came back in saying there was a guy with blond hair and blue eyes waiting outside, I almost died of a heart attack. It was James, a junior and the captain of the baseball team. He had send me 2 candy-grams so far that year with notes like “i hope to see you at the next dance” and I had kept them even though I ignored him in the hallways (and, even though my dancing career had ended in grade 8). Before my mother could get to the door and raise a quizzical eyebrow at him, I went to the door and raised a quizzical eyebrow myself, blocking my mother’s slow, interest-piqued gait coming from the kitchen. He wanted to know if I wanted to take a walk by the lake with him. I wanted to say can’t you see this big blue thing on my head? But instead, I mumbled sorry, I’m busy and closed the door. When I peeked through the peephole a while later, he was still there – now befuddled himself.

The terror of seeing that blond hair through the peephole of my home turf helped me steer clear of keeping candy-grams from then on. And by the end of high school, my father had begun discussing such topics as crushes and “interests” with us – with a very positive, almost over-eager manner. He was just trying to be a good, open father and I was just an embarrassed 17 year old, with snapping gum and crossed arms. After a while he gave up trying to find out our true feelings in a transparent way (“so my daughter, is there anyone you feel anything towards that you would like to tell me about so we can discuss it away?”). He dwindled down to explaining the Islamic view of such matters and we left it at that. I’m so glad now that he made it seem normal – this thing called love or, rather, this thing called the “stirrings of love”.

Amidst this deepening confusion, I embarked on the voyage called matrimony very early – I was the second from my large circle of friends to get hitched. The un-hitching (which is what I prefer to call it, the other word being shuddery) has caused me more confusion as to the matter of soulmates and this thing called…yes, you know.

But recently I read a beautiful essay by Sarah Polley entitled “On Marriage and Fiction” which lit another lantern in my head and yes, my heart. She wrote about Alice Munro’s short story “The Bear Came Over the Mountain” which Polley had turned into the recently released and critically-acclaimed film, Away From Her. She wrote about how the story left her weeping. She wrote “this story helped me move my idea of love – specifically unconditional love – into something much less melodramatic and typically cinematic, yet unfathomably deep and complicated in its own right.”

I’m beginning to see that’s how I’ve been seeing it too. There’s a site called Imagini VisualDNA which asks you to click on images which describe the way you define terms and every single time, for “Love is…”, I click on the image of an elderly couple smiling serenely at each other – not exactly the first image which comes to mind under the heading of love.

But I think that is what love is. Endurance, quiet and unquiet companionship, respectful spaces and the ability to weave mercy into a cover for each other. You know, a strollmate. That’s my definition of a soulmate.

13 Responses leave one →
  1. 2007 May 30
    marnini permalink

    Thank you for the Imagini Visual Dna site-I enjoyed it. I liked your story too.

  2. 2007 June 1

    I think some people mistake their strollmate for a soulmate. And perhaps that is better for them – you may want someone to accompany you on this journey called Life and that sharing may or may not necessarily involve that deep, inner sharing of the soul.

    With the above is companionship, and involves sharing of yourself, your dreams, aspirations, fears, sorrows – you are sharing a little bit of what contributes to you, and inevitably your soul is made up of all these components. It doesn’t need to adhere to some romance whilrwind, birds twittering, violins playing type atmosphere. Life often does not include background music, so too applies to love and soulmates.

    This companion may not seem like your soulmate initially but they might just grow into one over time; the same way you grow to love a pair of old shoes or a dress. Time and experience can do that to you; its a strange thing :)

    Thanks for this, I thoroughly enjoyed it :)

  3. 2007 June 1
    Anonymous permalink

    But I think that is what love is. Endurance, quiet and unquiet companionship, respectful spaces and the ability to weave mercy into a cover for each other.

    That’s a remarkable image. Whenever you create an image like that, you should hope and pray that time stops at that point, so that forever and always, you’ll just be finishing the sentence and preparing yourself to read it. I don’t think I agree with you, but I still like the image.
    I’ve often thought that my in-laws, the products of an arranged East African marriage, stay together out of spite. The daily annoyances boil over for them much too much–to me, it seems there’s always this palpable tension in the room when they’re together. Married life for them seems to be recommended but inconvenient. I compare that to my relations with my wife–we’re no Norman Rockwell painting, but everything is easy by comparison, at least to the naked eye. But then my father in law went away for a week, and I got a call in the middle of the night from his wife, and she couldn’t stop crying, and she was saying “I hope when we die, Allah takes us on the same minute because I can’t be without him.” Of course, I don’t think she’d give him the satisfaction of knowing she felt that. But maybe she tells him those things when there’s nobody else around.
    –A

  4. 2007 June 2

    marnini, thanks…

    Sumera, welcome and thanks for your comments. I guess what I’m trying to signify by a strollmate is the sense of tranquility which comes with being in a comfortable (and respectful) relationship. (which must be good for both the souls in it, n’est-ce pas?) And I really think our souls are destined for more than just nestling into that of another… though finding someone with whom you have that instant connection makes it more beautiful, I think the ultimate goal of our souls is to love and serve God. (i say this after growing out of being a miss marianne dashwood in such matters previously.)

    A, that was a touching (and funny) story. I know what you’re talking about – I’ve seen the same type of relationships (mainly among older people in our communities – many of whom, it seems, have been reared in the tradition of the “stiff upper lip” in the department of love; but like you say, it may be stiff in front of company and something else entirely in privacy.) And when you say you don’t agree with me, are you referring to my description of a soulmate?

  5. 2007 June 2

    Strollmate and soulmate. Your description is perfect. Who’s to say they’re not one and the same?

    Youth gets in the way of logic sometimes, confuses us, pushes us to make rushed decisions on things beyond our years. If I had a dollar for every mistake I made because I didn’t know the real definition of love, well I’d be rich.

    And how long does it really take us to learn the true meaning of love?

  6. 2007 June 2
    Anonymous permalink

    I know what you’re talking about – I’ve seen the same type of relationships (mainly among older people in our communities – many of whom, it seems, have been reared in the tradition of the “stiff upper lip” in the department of love

    Bang on, I think. And maybe for good reason — love’s tough. That’s why country music records sell so well.

    And when you say you don’t agree with me, are you referring to my description of a soulmate?

    Not so much your description of a soulmate as your description of love. I loved your use of “mercy” because human emotions that reflect our relationship with the Almighty are always rooted in mercy, and love’s no exception. But people who really love one another aren’t always merciful to one another–sometimes, they’re pretty damned far from mercy, and it gets that way because of the strength of their attachment to one another. You’ve talked about the ideal, but it can get messy on the ground. Unpleasant, even. Stormy. Again, that’s why country music sells so well.
    Thanks again, though, for such a great article.
    –A

  7. 2007 June 2

    Asmaa, from one DYJane Austen! group member to another: AGREED.
    A, I’ll have to disagree with your disagreement; messy and stormy love may be real, exciting or plainly tolerable to some but to others it may be so disquieting that it, in effect, breaks them. I think my parents are in love and they have for the most part demonstrated the kind of love I described. They’re not lovey-dovey but you can tell they find tranquility with each other. And, did I mention they love strolling together?

  8. 2007 June 6
    Sunshine Girl permalink

    Thanks for the Stroll mate thoughts. Often I find myself slicing bits of myself for everyone in my life and there is not enough of me left for myself. Jagjit Singh, the famous ghazal singer has this to say: “Itney hisson mein batt gaya hoon main, mere hisse mein kuch bachaa hi nahin” ( I have been divided into so many parts, there is nothing of me left for myself)
    And I realise that there are no easy answers, especially when trapped by expectations and societal conditioning. Spiritual needs and the needs of the soul, unmet, cause the stifling smog that we trudge through day after day. I know, I have for many years.
    Yet, I am not sure how one decides the path to stroll down. There are some parts of life that one shares with ones partner, others passions are sometimes unanswered. Sometimes life hands on a long awaited wish. Is it fair to myself turn away? My mother has this saying that unfulfilled yet yearned for dreams are based more on wishful thinking rather than hard facts ( but does the heart recognise that, I haven’t asked) Who knows, I am waiting for mine to knock on my door!!

  9. 2007 June 9
    Bumbaiya permalink

    dear commonplacer, you go from thinking about soulmates and go on to question what is love……

    …it may be difficult to connect with one person to share your varied passions and requirements. Someone for your physical wants and someone else as your spiritual quests, and another for intellectual needs. Now does any of the above or all of it need be provided by one person ? Does bonding with the person who can provide one or some or all of the above constitue love ? If I say I love you to someone, does it mean that the person is close to providing the most of your above requirements ? Can you say “I love you” to more than one person and mean it truthfully ?

  10. 2007 June 13
    Sunshine Girl permalink

    Some more thoughts on soul mates and change. There are times, I am my own soulmate. At times when I realise that the turmoil in my head makes sense to me alone, I do not that tide wash away the peace of others. I write. I scribble notes fo myself ( but Hugh Prather got there first, his Notes to Myself and Notes to Each Other are priceless gems).

    These days with the school year winding down ( yes I am a teacher too, grade 7s ) and the leaden skies filled with promise somedays find me at my melancholy best. Thank goodness for ghazals I say.

    I have come to realise that I dont have to have anyone to share my pleasure with. I can walk alone, I can write to myself, and I can calm myself down. As I have often said to my sister, ” Let us not look to others to calm our storms, that is too much pressure for them. Let us train ourselves to find our safe harbours for our own souls and let us cherich who we are” I think my quest for a soulmate as stilled since the day I found myself.

    Now whether I walk alone in the gathering dusk listening to the robin restore my calm, I miss my ‘koel’ of Mumbai little less. When I walk with my son after dinner, I miss my brothers a little less, and when I think of love found, lost and regained ( Milton would be proud) I realise that the most successful quest for a soulmate was the one in which I found myself.

    In peace.

  11. 2007 June 26

    I have fumbled around in my mind the very same question which you have posed here. What is love, or rather, what does it mean to feel love, to be loved, to be in love?

    Quite simply, I have come to a realization, that it doesn’t matter how much someone, or someones love you, but we all have to love ourselves first. When we have this confidence in ourselves, we can open ourselves to others.

  12. 2007 June 27

    Sunshine girl, bumbaiya and american muslim, thanks for further thoughts on this. A topic to be revisited I’m sure.

  13. 2008 August 29

    Love is like breathing
    Sometimes you only notice it
    Once it stops

    Your entry title is deceptive and had me hooked until I got to the end of your post and realized it was the opposite of what I was thinking when I began reading it.

    Your “Strollmate” insight is spot on!

    “… But I think that is what love is. Endurance, quiet and unquiet companionship, respectful spaces and the ability to weave mercy into a cover for each other. You know, a strollmate. That’s my definition of a soulmate. …”

    Upon reflection I need to update how I began this comment…

    Love is like strolling
    Sometimes you only notice it
    Once the walking stops

    SubhanAllah, I miss my strollmate.

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS